
Guides
Medicare billing for chiropractors, what CMS changed and what to document
Chiropractic provider billing for Medicare turns on the AT modifier, active treatment proof, and clean documentation that survives OIG review.
What to take away
- Chiropractic provider billing under Medicare Part B pays only for active treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine, and the AT modifier is what tells the contractor the treatment is active.
- Medicare pays for the manipulation itself. Exams, x-rays, massage, ultrasound, and most modalities are statutorily excluded, so they are the patient's responsibility or another payer's.
- Medicare Advantage plans set their own coverage rules, which are often broader than Original Medicare, so the same visit can be covered by one plan and denied by another.
- CMS documentation expectations and OIG documentation expectations overlap: the record must show the subluxation, the level treated, the method, the patient's response, and the treatment plan.
- Maintenance care is not a covered Medicare benefit, so the AT modifier comes off once the patient is stable.
- Coding errors and cloned notes are the two failures that drive most chiropractic Medicare repayments, so internal review matters more than volume.
How the Medicare chiropractic benefit is defined under CMS rules
The Medicare chiropractic benefit is one of the narrowest benefits in Part B. Congress limited it to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation demonstrated by x-ray or physical exam. That language is the whole benefit. Nothing else a chiropractor does in a typical visit falls inside it.
A subluxation, for Medicare purposes, is a motion segment in which alignment, movement integrity, or physiologic function is altered, though the spinal nerves remain intact. The definition is a coverage definition, not a clinical philosophy. If the record does not describe a subluxation at a specific level, the claim has no covered service to stand on.
The benefit also requires that the manipulation be active treatment. Active treatment means the patient's condition is expected to improve, or the care is for a recent injury or flare. Care given after maximum therapeutic benefit has been reached is maintenance therapy, and Medicare does not pay for it.
A few services ride along in some circumstances. If a manipulation is covered, the evaluation and management service on the same day may be payable when it is significant and separately identifiable. Everything else, including extremity manipulation, is outside the benefit.
New practice owners often assume a license and an NPI are enough to bill Medicare. They are not. Enrollment, documentation habits, and an understanding of the benefit's boundaries come first, which is why a compliance checklist for new owners is worth building before the first claim goes out.
What the benefit does not include
- Physical therapy modalities such as ultrasound, electrical stimulation, and traction
- Massage therapy and manual therapy that is not spinal manipulation
- X-rays and other diagnostic imaging
- Orthopedic supplies, braces, and supports
- Acupuncture and dry needling
- Nutritional counseling and most patient education
A patient who receives any of these on the same date as a covered manipulation may still owe for them. Tell the patient in advance and keep a signed notice in the record.
Who can bill it
Only a chiropractor enrolled in Medicare, or a physician or osteopath performing the same service, may bill. Chiropractors enroll as a supplier, not as a physician, which changes the enrollment form and the fee schedule that applies. A chiropractor cannot bill for services incident to a physician's care.
What CMS changed, and what did not
The chiropractic benefit itself has not changed. Federal law still covers only manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation, and the Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 15, states that limit in the same terms it always has.
Two rule changes matter in practice.
The AT modifier. CMS requires the modifier on claims for 98940 through 98942 so the contractor can tell active treatment from maintenance, and claims without it are denied. The rule is long standing. It has not been relaxed.
Medicare Advantage. CMS required Medicare Advantage plans to apply the same coverage criteria as Original Medicare. The requirement came from the contract year 2023 Medicare Advantage final rule and was phased in for the 2024 contract year. A plan may still pay for more, because a plan can offer a broader benefit than Part B.
Neither change added a covered service under Original Medicare. Exams, imaging, and modalities stay outside the benefit, and maintenance manipulation stays non-covered.
The AT modifier rule and when manual manipulation of the spine is covered
The AT modifier rule is simple on its face and unforgiving in practice. AT, defined as acute treatment, is appended to the CPT code for the spinal manipulation to certify that the service is active treatment, not maintenance. The AT modifier rule exists because the code itself does not distinguish the two.
When a claim for 98940, 98941, or 98942 arrives without AT, Medicare contractors treat it as maintenance therapy and deny it. The modifier is not a billing preference. It is the condition of payment.
Some contractors have asked for documentation of the AT modifier's basis, so the note must actually support active care. A record that describes unchanged symptoms for eight weeks while the AT modifier stays on every claim invites a denial and a repayment demand.
What active treatment looks like in the note
What active treatment looks like
- A recent onset, a new injury, or a documented flare of a chronic condition
- Objective findings that change over the course of care
- A treatment plan with expected goals and a planned re-examination
- Progress toward those goals, or a documented reason progress is slow
When the AT modifier should come off
When the patient reaches maximum therapeutic benefit, the AT modifier should come off and the claims should stop. Continuing to bill Medicare with AT after stabilization is the single most common compliance failure in chiropractic Medicare billing.
The manual manipulation codes
| CPT code | What it describes | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| 98940 | Chiropractic manipulative treatment, spinal, 1 to 2 regions | Short or focused visits |
| 98941 | Chiropractic manipulative treatment, spinal, 3 to 4 regions | Most common Medicare claim |
| 98942 | Chiropractic manipulative treatment, spinal, 5 regions | Full spine treatment |
| 98943 | Chiropractic manipulative treatment, extraspinal, 1 or more regions | Not covered by Medicare |
The region count must match the note. If the note documents cervical and thoracic treatment, 98940 is defensible. If it documents five regions, 98942 applies. Contractors compare the code to the treated levels, and a mismatch is a coding error even when the care was appropriate.
Medicare Part B versus Medicare Advantage billing for chiropractors
Medicare Part B versus Medicare Advantage billing is where most front-desk confusion starts. Original Medicare is administered by Medicare Administrative Contractors under national and local coverage rules. Medicare Advantage is administered by private plans under a contract with CMS, and those plans may cover more than Original Medicare does.
Many Medicare Advantage plans cover maintenance visits, exams, and modalities that Part B excludes. Others follow Part B almost exactly. There is no single answer, so the plan's evidence of coverage and provider manual govern each patient.
That difference matters for chiropractic provider billing at the front desk. Staff should verify the plan type before the visit, not after the denial. A patient who moved from Original Medicare to a Medicare Advantage plan may find that care previously denied is now covered, or the reverse.
Practical differences to track
Part B vs Medicare Advantage
Original Medicare Part B
- Prior authorization
- Generally not required
- Visit limits
- No fixed cap
- AT modifier
- Required for payment
- Documentation requests
- Contractor articles
- Appeals
- MAC process
Medicare Advantage
- Prior authorization
- Some plans require it
- Visit limits
- May cap per year
- AT modifier
- May or may not require
- Documentation requests
- Plans often request notes
- Appeals
- Goes to the plan
- Maintenance careexcluded under Part B, sometimes covered by a Medicare Advantage plan
- Exams and imagingexcluded under Part B, often covered by a plan
- Claim destinationthe Medicare Administrative Contractor for Part B, the plan for Medicare Advantage
- Prior authorizationrare in Part B, common in Medicare Advantage
- Payment basisthe Medicare Physician Fee Schedule for Part B, the plan's own rate for Medicare Advantage
- Appealsredetermination through the contractor for Part B, the plan's process and then the independent review entity for Medicare Advantage
Credentialing and enrollment
A chiropractor must be credentialed with each Medicare Advantage plan separately. Being enrolled in Medicare and having an NPI does not automatically put a provider in network. Credentialing takes weeks to months, and the paperwork a chiropractic practice needs grows with each plan, so start early and track expiration dates.
Billing mechanics
Medicare Advantage claims go to the plan, not to the Medicare Administrative Contractor, unless the plan uses a delegated arrangement. Eligibility, benefits, and authorization requirements all live with the plan. Build a one-page cheat sheet per payer with the portal, the authorization rule, and the appeal address.
Documentation CMS and OIG expect in the chiropractic record
CMS documentation expectations come from the coverage rule and the contractor articles that explain it. OIG documentation expectations come from audit findings and compliance guidance. They point at the same record elements, and a note built for one will usually satisfy the other.
The Medicare Learning Network booklet Chiropractic Services states the coverage rule and the documentation it requires in the same terms.
The record must show the subluxation, the specific spinal level or levels, the method of manipulation, and the patient's response. It must also show that the care is active treatment, which is what the AT modifier certifies. If any of those pieces is missing, the claim is vulnerable.
The core elements
Core documentation elements
- History with onset and character
- Exam findings with segmental level
- Diagnosis matching findings and level
- Treatment method and levels adjusted
- Patient response and next visit plan
- Signature and date on every entry
- The subluxation, described as a motion segment with altered alignment, movement, or function
- The specific spinal level or levels treated
- The method of manipulation used
- The patient's response, with an objective finding where the note can carry one
- A treatment plan with goals and a re-examination date
- Evidence that improvement is expected, which is what active treatment means
- Date of service, treating provider, and a signature
What auditors flag
What auditors flag
- Identical notes across dates
- Treatment levels not matching diagnosis
- Missing or inconsistent AT modifier
- Care past stabilization without reason
- Records not identifying who performed service
- Diagnosis codes not supporting level treated
- The same findings and the same wording repeated on different dates
- No measurable change in findings across several visits
- AT on every claim for months on end
- An open-ended plan with no goals and no re-examination
- Levels documented in the note that do not match the code billed
- Services billed that the benefit excludes
- No documented response to care
A worked example
A 54-year-old patient presents with three weeks of low back pain after lifting. The exam shows a subluxation at L4 and L5 with reduced range of motion. The chiropractor adjusts two regions, documents the change in range of motion, and sets a re-examination in four weeks. The claim is 98940 with AT and a matching diagnosis.
Four weeks later the findings have improved, so care continues. At week ten the findings are stable and the patient feels well between visits. The AT modifier comes off, and the patient is told maintenance care is not a Medicare benefit.
That sequence is defensible. The same ten visits with the same note copied each time are not.
Sample note wording
A note does not need to be long. It needs the five elements, written in the chiropractor's own words for that date.
- Subluxation
- segmental dysfunction at L4 and L5, with fixation and reduced lumbar range of motion
- Level
- L4 and L5, two regions, which the note matches to 98940
- Method
- manual manipulation, specific contact, prone
- Response
- lumbar flexion improved since the last visit and pain on extension has eased
- Plan
- twice a week for three weeks, then re-examination. Active treatment, so the claim carries AT
Each visit keeps the same five headings and changes the findings. Copying last week's response is the error auditors look for.
Where coding and documentation meet
Diagnosis coding runs on the ICD-10-CM set, and the codes must describe the condition being treated at the level adjusted. Coders and billers should work from the note, not from the schedule. The ICD-10 | CMS pages carry the current code set and updates.
The CPT Code Information pages from the AMA carry the code descriptors and guidelines that drive 98940 through 98943. HCPCS covers the supplies and other items that occasionally appear on a chiropractic claim, and CMS publishes the Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System (HCPCS) | CMS files that list them.
Good notes also make month-end reporting cleaner. Practices that track denial rates and days in accounts receivable alongside clinical measures find problems faster, and the monthly KPIs worth watching include the AT modifier denial rate and the share of claims paid on first submission.
Maintenance care, medical necessity, and the limits of coverage
Maintenance care is the boundary line of the Medicare chiropractic benefit. CMS treats maintenance therapy as care given to maintain or prevent deterioration of a chronic condition, or to prevent a recurrence, once the patient's condition has stabilized. It is not a covered service.
The test is not how the patient feels on a given day. It is whether the condition is expected to improve with further treatment. If the answer is no, the care is maintenance.
Medical necessity for chiropractic care means the manipulation is reasonable and necessary for the diagnosis, meets accepted standards, and is not more than the patient needs. Contractors look for an expectation of improvement and a plan that reflects it.
Signs care has shifted to maintenance
Signs of maintenance care
- No symptom change over several visits
- Stable objective findings across re-examinations
- Fixed-interval visits with no clinical trigger
- Patient says visits keep them feeling good
- No goals left in the treatment plan
- Findings that are unchanged at two or more re-examinations
- A patient who reports feeling well between visits
- A plan with no goals and no end date
- Care that continues for months after the original problem resolved
- Visits scheduled to prevent a recurrence rather than to treat a flare
- A standing request to keep coming regardless of the findings
How to handle the transition
Tell the patient in writing that further care is maintenance and not covered by Medicare. Offer a written notice and a private fee arrangement, following state and federal rules on beneficiary notices. Document the conversation. Then stop billing Medicare for those visits.
The difference between maintenance and a flare
A patient in maintenance care can still have a covered episode. A new injury or a documented flare that is expected to improve restarts active treatment. The record should show the new onset, the change in findings, and a new plan. Without that, the claim looks like maintenance with a different label.
Why this matters financially
Denials for maintenance care usually arrive long after the visits, which means repayment of money already spent. Practices that carry thin reserves feel it immediately, which is one reason a chiropractic practice plan belongs in the same conversation as clinical documentation. Set aside a reserve for potential recoupment rather than treating every collected dollar as profit.
Coding chiropractic claims with CPT and HCPCS for Medicare payers
Coding for Medicare chiropractic claims is narrow by design. The spinal manipulation codes are the core, and the AT modifier is the flag that makes them payable. Everything else on the claim must be justified or left off.
Evaluation and management codes may be billed on the same day as a manipulation when the evaluation is significant and separately identifiable. The note must support both services, and the documentation cannot be a single blended paragraph. If the evaluation is routine and part of the manipulation visit, do not bill it separately.
HCPCS codes apply to supplies and equipment, not to the manipulation itself. Orthopedic braces, pillows, and similar items may have HCPCS codes, but Medicare coverage for them is limited and often falls under a different benefit with its own rules. Check coverage before dispensing.
A clean claim checklist
Clean claim checklist
- Patient enrolled and eligible on date
- Plan type confirmedOriginal or Advantage
- Diagnosis codes match levels treated
- CPT code matches spinal regions treated
- AT modifier present for active treatment
- E/M code supported separately if billed
- ABN on file for non-covered care
- Note signed and dated by chiropractor
- The CPT code matches the number of regions documented in the note
- AT is on the claim for active care and off once care is maintenance
- The diagnosis code supports the level treated
- The note is dated, signed, and carries the five core elements
- Eligibility and plan type were verified before the visit
- Evaluation and management was billed only when separately identifiable
- A signed notice is on file for services the patient will owe
Common coding errors
Billing 98942 when the note supports three regions is an upcoding error. Billing 98943 for an extremity adjustment on a Medicare claim is a coverage error. Billing an evaluation and management code when the note does not support a separately identifiable service is a bundling error. Each of these is avoidable with a second look before submission.
Modifiers beyond AT
Some contractors and plans ask for modifiers that describe the service setting or a reduced service. Use them only when the payer's policy calls for them. A modifier applied without a documented reason creates a mismatch between the claim and the note.
Keeping the codes current
The code sets change every year. Assign one person to review the annual updates to CPT, HCPCS, and ICD-10-CM before January 1, and update the fee schedule and the claim templates at the same time. Written standards that include coding rules keep the whole team on the same page when staff turn over.
Audit exposure: what the OIG Work Plan flags for chiropractic billing
The OIG Work Plan is the list of audit targets the Office of Inspector General intends to review. Chiropractic services have appeared on it repeatedly under the title Medicare Part B Payments for Chiropractic Services, usually focused on whether Medicare paid for maintenance therapy billed as active treatment.
The plan is reissued each fiscal year, so an item can drop off and return.
The Work Plan | Office of Inspector General | Government Oversight | U.S. Department of Health and Human Services is public, and reading it is a cheap way to see where contractors will look next.
Audits typically start with data analysis. The OIG compares the number of AT claims per beneficiary, the duration of care, and the pattern of visits across providers. Outliers get requests for records. A records request in these audits typically covers 30 to 100 claims. From there the review is a document-by-document judgment about whether each visit was active treatment.
What triggers a review
OIG review triggers
- High volume of 98941 and 98942 claims
- Long courses with no gap or re-exam
- Same note text across many dates
- AT modifier on nearly every claim
- Diagnosis codes that do not change
- A high number of AT claims per beneficiary
- Long episodes of care with no documented improvement
- Utilization well above peers in the same specialty and area
- Identical documentation across dates or across patients
- Excluded services billed alongside a covered manipulation
- Beneficiary complaints
- Claims corrected and resubmitted after a denial for the same service
What happens if the OIG finds a problem
The result is usually a demand for repayment, and in serious cases a referral for civil or administrative action. Providers can reduce exposure by running their own reviews first. Pull ten records a month, score them against the coverage rule, and fix what fails.
The OIG's physician education materials, including A Roadmap for New Physicians | Office of Inspector General | Government Oversight | U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, explain the compliance principles that apply to chiropractors as suppliers, including the rules on billing for services that were not medically necessary.
Building a compliance routine
- Audit a sample of Medicare claims every month
- Track denials by reason code and fix the cause, not just the claim
- Train new staff on the AT modifier rule before they touch a claim
- Keep a written policy on maintenance care and beneficiary notices
- Review the OIG Work Plan and contractor articles each year
The cost of getting it wrong
A repayment demand can reach back three years, the standard Medicare reopening period. For a practice billing Medicare steadily, that number can exceed a year of profit. The dollar figure depends on how many AT claims sit in the lookback window and how many fail review. The defense is not a better appeal.
It is a record that shows, visit by visit, that the patient was improving and the care was active.







